5 recruitment changes employers can make now to give NEET young people a first chance

The Milburn Review’s funding proposals will take time to agree. How an organisation assesses, rejects and supports young applicants is in its own hands. 

Nearly 1 million young people, around 1 in 8, are not in education, employment or training (NEET), and 6 in 10 of them have never had a job. The final report of Alan Milburn’s review: From a Welfare State to a Working State, was published on 17 November 2026. Most of the coverage has focused on what the government should fund. Less attention has gone to a point the review makes repeatedly: many young people are being filtered out by recruitment processes that test familiarity with recruitment, not ability to do the job, and that insist on assessing prior experience for entry-level roles. That leaves them in a catch-22: they need a first job to gain experience but need experience to get a first job. 

That is something employers can change without waiting for legislation or new funding. It also matters to them commercially. Early careers roles left unfilled, or filled by candidates who leave within weeks, cost time and money. In our experience at Omni RMS, the organisations that redesign how they assess and support people who are new to work fill more of those roles. 

Why capable candidates fall out of the process

The review finds that entry-level vacancies have fallen by 49% over the past decade, and that entry-level recruitment has become more formal, more remote, and increasingly automated. Fewer openings and more screening steps mean each application carries more weight, and young people with no work history have the least to show at each step. 

The review describes a catch-22 in which entry-level roles ask for the confidence, reliability and workplace know-how that people usually only develop once they are in work. Access to early experience is uneven too: 39% of NEET respondents had done work experience at secondary school, compared with 56% of those who were not NEET. The review also cites research showing that equally qualified applicants from ethnic minority backgrounds had to send 60% more applications than their white British peers to get a positive response. 

The process itself can be the barrier. The review notes that a young person can be rejected for doing badly in a recorded interview or for not knowing how an automated application system works, and neither tells an employer whether they could become a capable technician, care worker or administrator. Then there is the silence. Young people told the review about applying for job after job without a reply, and about rejections arriving months later for roles they had forgotten applying for. Each one makes the next application harder to start. 

"I think we sometimes forget just how daunting the recruitment process can be for someone who has never had a job. We've become so focused on speed and efficiency that we've lost sight of the need to give people a genuine chance to show what they're capable of. If we want to give more young people a first chance, we need to think differently about how we hire. Help them prepare for interviews, assess their potential rather than how polished their answers are, and recognise that confidence and workplace skills are often things we develop through experience, not before it." Richard Bradley, Commercial Director, Omni RMS

5 changes employers can make now 

 

1. Ask only for what the role needs on day 1 

The review asks employers to remove experience requirements a role does not genuinely need, and to write clear job descriptions. A practical test is to go through each requirement in an early careers advert and ask whether you would train a new starter in it anyway. If you would, it belongs in the description of what you will teach, not in the list of what applicants must already have. Qualifications and experience should stay where the role genuinely requires them. 

2. Assess potential, not polish 

In our experience, competency interviews reward people who have already worked and know how to talk about it. The review recommends more practical assessment, supported interviews and work trials, which let candidates show what they can do. Telling candidates in advance what each stage involves, and what good looks like, removes an advantage that currently goes to those with family or professional contacts to ask. 

This is where our work with National Highways started. We redesigned how candidates who are new to work are assessed, and the support they receive from application through to onboarding. The programme achieved 98% fulfilment across 115 early careers roles, including apprenticeships. 

3. Test your automated sift before it tests candidates 

The review asks employers to test automated recruitment for barriers unrelated to the job. In our view, the simplest starting point is to look at pass rates at each stage of the process, using aggregated and anonymised data, and ask where candidates who are new to work drop out and why. Where screening is automated, employers should also check against current UK data protection rules on automated decision-making, on which the Information Commissioner’s Office publishes guidance. 

4. Use the time automation saves to answer the people you reject 

Early careers roles can attract large numbers of applications, and the first sift is increasingly automated. We think the time that saves should go into the part of recruitment candidates remember how they are turned down. The review asks larger employers in particular to change their processes so that rejected applicants get a response and, where possible, feedback they can use next time. 

The Co-op Career Development Hub, which Omni RMS developed with the Co-op, and which is featured in the review, shows one way to do this at volume. Unsuccessful candidates receive a personalised email inviting them to register. The hub includes a personalised employability assessment and development plan, CV and cover-letter tools, interview simulations with AI-generated guidance, and more than 1,000 e-learning resources. It is mobile-first, so people with limited IT skills or without a computer can use it, and the Co-op also offers it to school-leavers, employees at risk of redundancy and community partners. A rejection becomes the start of the candidate’s next application, wherever they make it. 

5. Keep supporting people after the offer 

Candidates can still drop out between offer and start date. The review notes that employers are carrying out a growing pastoral burden as more young people arrive with complex needs. Planned contact between offer and start, a named person to call with questions and early check-ins in the first weeks all reduce the chance of losing a new starter before they have settled.

What government has proposed, and what is still open 

The review proposes a bargain in which employers create more first chances and government makes doing so cheaper and simpler. It recommends a £3,000 payment to employers who hire a young person who has been NEET for 6 months, an extra £2,000 for those facing greater barriers, such as care leavers or disabled young people, and a further £2,000 for organisations with fewer than 50 employees. It also proposes raising the apprenticeship payment to £2,500 and extending it to Levy payers, and creating a single front door for employers, the Youth Opportunity Service. The review estimates the package at around £1.1 billion a year once scaled up, creating an additional 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities. 

The review is also candid about the pressure on employers: wage costs for 18 to 20 year-olds on the minimum wage have risen by 65% over 5 years. These are recommendations, not agreed upon policy, and the government’s response will decide how much of the package arrives. 

Alongside the funding, the review asks employers to join First Chance, an employer-led movement with 3 asks: more genuine first jobs, more youth apprenticeships and wider access to work experience. It suggests large employers aim for 10% of entry-level vacancies to go to young people who are NEET or at risk of becoming so. 

Where to start 

We would suggest one exercise before any new scheme: take a single early careers process and follow it from the job advert to the rejection email, as a candidate with no work history would experience it. At each stage, ask whether it tests ability to do the job or experience of applying for jobs, and count how many candidates leave at that point. In our experience, most organisations find at least one stage that filters out people they would have been glad to hire. 

Contact Us

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name(Required)

Get in touch today to discuss how you can improve your hiring process