Why Culture Contribution is More Important Than Culture Fit

Stephen Covey, the author of ‘7 Habits of Highly Effective People’, famously said, “Life is not accumulation, it is about contribution” and although that was published back in 1989, these words still resonate today. Many organisations talk about culture fit in their recruitment processes and prioritise those candidates in a selection process that they feel will fit into their existing workplace culture. However, recently the importance of cultural contribution – what individuals can actively bring to their roles – is challenging for prominence. Here, we look at what it is and how it can contribute to the success of an organisation.

What is cultural contribution?

Organisations, understandably, look for candidates who would be a good fit for both the organisation and the role. However, too frequently hiring managers are influenced by their unconscious biases which make them feel more inclined towards candidates that are more ‘like’ them or their existing team, and when asked to justify a decision to regret a candidate from a recruitment process will describe the ‘culture fit’ mismatch. Whilst it is prudent and valid to seek to ensure that candidates are able to operate effectively in a particular work environment, if you’re merely interested in hiring people who are exactly like you, in reality it can lead to stagnation, with fewer different perspectives or experiences contributing to problem solving and continuous improvements.

Cultural contribution turns the situation on its head and asks not whether the applicant will fit into the existing organisational culture, but rather what that individual can actively contribute towards the culture to enhance it, drive it forward and keep it current.

Equity, diversity & inclusion

One way to ensure cultural contribution is built into an organisation is to embrace diversity. Many organisations now put diversity at the heart of their recruitment policies and embrace the legal, moral and ethical case for Equity, Diversity and Inclusion (EDI). This broadly means rejecting discrimination on the grounds of a range of both legally protected characteristics such as age, ethnicity and gender and also unprotected characteristics such as: socioeconomic background, educational attainment and traits such as introversion or extraversion, and welcoming individuals who can help increase the diversity of thought and experience in the organisation.

The benefits for both organisations and the individuals who take a cultural contribution approach are many. The CIPD (Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development) makes the case that EDI has a positive psychological effect on employees, making them feel valued and respected. As a result, better quality work is produced, creativity levels are higher, and employees experience an overall sense of improved mental and physical wellbeing.

For employers, successful ED&I policies give organisations a competitive advantage. Open and inclusive workplaces have been seen have better retention rates and have demonstrated increased levels of innovation. By creating a diverse and inclusive workplace, you are not only making the environment more accessible to a wider pool of talent, but you are consistently bringing in fresh perspectives to elevate your workforce.

Disruptive thinking

In a highly viewed TED Talk entitled ‘Are you a giver or a taker?’, Organisational Psychologist Adam Grant breaks down workplace personalities into three types: Givers, Takers and Matchers. He says, “…research shows that the frequency of giving behaviour that exists in a team or organisation, and the more often people help and share their knowledge… the better organisations do on every metric we can measure, [resulting in]  higher profits, employee retention and lower operating costs.He finishes his talk by affirming, success is about contribution.

Cultural contribution can be likened to challenging the status quo, with the aim of supporting the evolution of an organisation, pushing it in areas that it might not have previously considered, and driving change for the betterment of not only the company but also its workforce.

For candidates, it’s about offering potential employers something they don’t currently have. For organisations and hiring managers it’s about actively encouraging and advocating for diversity of thought, experience and style. Cultural contribution shouldn’t be seen as simply a box-ticking exercise, but rather, embraced as a real chance to bring a fresh set of eyes to the workplace, and thus further skills and ideas as a result. It requires both awareness and insight on the part of employers to bring in individuals who can broaden the perspective of the organisation or of a specific team. Today’s workplaces are evolving into spaces where values and ethics are seen to be key drivers of performance and results, but it’s important that this doesn’t result in an introspective monoculture of groupthink, where nothing is challenged, and few new ideas are presented. Diverse input is vital to innovation and growth, both for organisations and for the individuals who work within them.


One way to introduce cultural contribution in the workplace is for employers to rethink the hiring process, by ensuring that the candidate attraction and assessment processes are truly inclusive and result in hires that bring with them new and diverse perspectives.

Omni’s Resourcing Effectiveness Assessment, which benchmarks an organisation’s effectiveness against 16 key resourcing areas, specifically considers how inclusive processes are (attraction and selection) and considers how the employer brand and candidate experience can be optimised for inclusion. Here at Omni, we change the way organisations resource for the better, as well as offering outsourced recruitment services.

Get in touch today to find out how we can help to ensure culture contribution is a part of your future hiring process.

 


 

Get in touch with us today to discuss your talent strategy needs.

Talent Strategy FAQs

Absolutely. Omni’s development centres are specifically designed to unlock the potential of your existing employees. Our structured assessments, aligned to your internal frameworks, are designed to identify individuals’ strengths, skills gaps, and areas for improvement, informing targeted developmental activities that drive real impact on individual and organisational performance.

Our assessment solutions are designed to elevate your hiring process by identifying the best candidates based on their skills, potential, and fit for the role. We help you define the critical competencies required for success, develop tailored assessments that accurately evaluate these competencies, and provide deep insights into candidates’ aptitude and personality traits. This evidence-based approach improves productivity, reduces turnover, and ensures a positive candidate experience. There are several benefits that personality profiling can bring to the recruitment process, such as supporting inclusive hiring, improved decision making, and increased efficiency.

Omni enhances your Employer Brand by presenting your organisation in a way that resonates with different candidate personas. By identifying these personas through rigorous market research and engaging them where they spend time online, Omni ensures that your recruitment marketing is relevant and broadens your access to talent. This approach pulls on relevant levers that are important to candidates’ values and drivers. Enhancing the employer brand to attract and retain talent remains one of the top key trends in recruitment and Omni’s Talent Strategy team can help your organisation do so.

The Resourcing Effectiveness Assessment (REA) is a rapid and flexible audit of an organisation’s resourcing maturity. The REA takes an integrated approach with key data derived from surveying recent hires, regretted candidates, and hiring managers; focus groups with strategic leaders, hiring managers and HR/TA teams; align with desktop research. Evaluation uses Omni’s four-level maturity index across five key areas: Strategy, People & Experience, Process, Tech & Data and EDI, with a further 20 sub-categories.

 

faq-shape

Our Talent Strategy Services